July 26, 2025

156 The Murder of Captain Marty Theer

156 The Murder of Captain Marty Theer

When U.S. Air Force Captain Marty Theer was gunned down in a Fayetteville parking lot just days before Christmas in 2000, authorities were baffled. But as investigators unraveled the case, they discovered a tangled web of lies, betrayal, and a deadly love triangle. At the center? His wife, Michelle Theer — a seemingly sweet marriagecounselor with dark secrets and a dangerous lover.

In this episode of Crimes, Killers, Cults and Beer, we dive deep into the shocking murder-for-hire plot that rocked a military community and sparked a national media frenzy. From internet affairs to cold-blooded conspiracy, this is the story of how love, lust, and manipulation led to murder.

Grab a drink, and join us as we explore the twisted case of Marty and Michelle Theer — because sometimes, the most dangerous people are the ones closest to you.


Got a beer you want Doug toreview? Send him an email at ckcbeer@gmail.com

Any other podcastcorrespondence, send it to ckcbpodcast@gmail.com

https://www.instagram.com/crimeskillerscultsandbeer/

https://twitter.com/CKC_Beer

https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCUyuqDB2Dlszhpc_pGca29whttps://www.facebook.com/groups/257328477392782/